Design Decisions Matrix for Stick-to-Skin Devices

Adhesive Type	Skin Compatibility	Adhesion Strength	Removal Ease	Cost	Best Applications	Limitations
Silicone-Based	EXCELLENT Hypoallergenic, gentle removal	GOOD Moderate-strong adhesion	EXCELLENT Pain-free removal	HIGH $$$	Extended wear devices, sensitive skin, pediatric/geriatric	Higher cost, potential for edge lifting in high-moisture environments
Acrylic-Based	GOOD Generally well-tolerated	EXCELLENT Very strong adhesion	FAIR May require adhesive remover	LOW $	Active patients, short-term wear, high-stress applications	Potential irritation, aggressive removal, sensitization risk
Hydrocolloid	EXCELLENT Breathable, moisture-managing	GOOD Swells with moisture	GOOD Gentle, self-releasing	MEDIUM $$	Wound care, high-exudate applications, extended wear	Limited electronic integration, thickness, moisture-dependent performance

Wear Duration	Recommended Adhesive	Backing Material	Key Design Considerations	Typical Applications	Regulatory Focus
Hours (1 - 24)	Acrylic or Medical-grade pressure-sensitive	Polyurethane film, Non-woven fabric	Easy application, cost optimization, immediate adhesion	Surgical monitoring, procedure-specific patches, diagnostic tests	510(k) Simplified, Basic Biocompatibility
Days (1 - 7)	Silicone or Modified acrylic	Breathable polyurethane, MVTR-optimized films	Moisture management, edge integrity, comfort optimization	Continuous glucose monitoring, cardiac patches, wound dressings	510(k) Standard, Extended Contact Testing
Days (7 - 30)	Advanced silicone systems	Multi-layer constructions, reinforced edges	Long-term biocompatibility, skin health maintenance, secure attachment	Implantable sensor interfaces, chronic monitoring systems	PMA Pathway, Chronic Contact Studies

Activity Level	Mechanical Stress	Adhesive Requirements	Design Features	Testing Requirements	Cost Impact
Sedentary (Limited Mobility)	LOW Minimal stretching/movement	Standard adhesion strength, comfort-focused	Thin profile, breathable materials, easy application	Basic peel testing, skin irritation assessment	LOW $
Active (Daily Activities)	MEDIUM Regular movement, some sweating	Enhanced adhesion, moisture resistance	Flexible backing, sweat-proof edges, reinforced attachment	Dynamic peel testing, moisture exposure, wear simulation	MEDIUM $$
Sports/Athletic (High Intensity)	HIGH Extreme stretching, heavy perspiration	Maximum adhesion strength, waterproof performance	Ultra-flexible materials, advanced edge sealing, impact resistance	Extreme condition testing, sports-specific validation, durability studies	HIGH $$$

Population	Skin Characteristics	Design Priorities	Material Considerations	Regulatory Requirements	Special Testing
Pediatric (0 - 17 years)	Thinner, more sensitive, rapid growth	Gentle adhesion, colorful/fun design, parent-friendly application	Hypoallergenic silicones, latex-free, smaller sizes	Pediatric Study Plan, Age-specific labeling	Pediatric skin model testing, age-appropriate usability studies
Adult (18 - 64 years)	Normal thickness, variable sensitivity, active lifestyle	Performance optimization, lifestyle integration, cost-effectiveness	Standard medical-grade adhesives, versatile backing materials	Standard 510(k), CE Mark	Standard biocompatibility panel, real-world use validation
Geriatric (65+ years)	Fragile, thin, slower healing, medications affect skin	Minimal trauma removal, high visibility design, caregiver-friendly	Ultra-gentle silicones, fragile skin-specific formulations	Elderly-specific studies, Medication interaction assessment	Fragile skin testing, medication interaction studies, caregiver usability

Cost Component	Low-Cost Option	Mid-Range Option	Premium Option	Performance Trade-Offs	Volume Considerations
Adhesive Materials	Basic acrylic $0.10-0.25/unit	Modified acrylic/Silicone blend $0.25-0.60/unit	Advanced silicone systems $0.60-1.50/unit	Skin compatibility vs. adhesion strength vs. removal gentleness	Economies at 100K+ units/year
Backing Materials	Standard PU film $0.05-0.15/unit	Breathable films/Non-wovens $0.15-0.35/unit	Multi-layer engineered films $0.35-0.80/unit	Comfort vs. moisture management vs. durability vs. flexibility	Custom materials require 500K+ units
Manufacturing Complexity	Simple die-cut patches $0.20-0.40/unit	Multi-layer lamination $0.40-0.80/unit	Electronics integration $2.00-10.00/unit	Functionality vs. complexity vs. quality control requirements	Automation viable at 1M+ units/year
Regulatory / Testing	Basic biocompatibility $50-100K total	Extended testing panel $100-250K total	Clinical studies required $250K-1M+ total	Time to market vs. regulatory risk vs. clinical evidence strength	One-time cost spread over product lifetime

Assumptions & METHODOLOGY

This design decision matrix provides comprehensive guidance for stick-to-skin medical device development based on industry standards, clinical requirements, and manufacturing benchmarks as of 2024. Recommendations synthesize data from adhesive manufacturers, contract manufacturing partners, regulatory submissions, and real-world clinical applications across multiple device categories. Adhesive Performance Parameters: Adhesive classifications (silicone-based, acrylic-based, hydrocolloid) reflect medical-grade materials meeting ISO 10993 biocompatibility standards. Performance ratings (Excellent/Good/Fair) are derived from comparative testing data including peel strength (ASTM D3330), shear adhesion resistance, and skin reaction studies. Cost ranges ($0.10-1.50/unit) assume 25cm² device footprint with medical-grade certification and represent volume pricing at 100,000 units annually. Wear Duration Specifications: Duration categories (Hours: 1-24, Days: 1-7, Days: 7-30) align with FDA contact duration classifications and typical clinical applications. Adhesive recommendations and backing material specifications are based on moisture vapor transmission rate (MVTR) requirements ranging from 500-1200 g/m²/24hr. Regulatory pathway guidance reflects current FDA 510(k) and PMA requirements with associated biocompatibility testing per ISO 10993 standards. Activity Level Assessments: Mechanical stress categories (Low/Medium/High) incorporate data from accelerometer studies and sweat exposure testing. Design features and testing requirements scale with anticipated patient activity, from sedentary post-surgical recovery through high-intensity athletic applications. Cost impacts reflect additional material and testing requirements for enhanced durability. Population-Specific Adaptations: Age-based categories account for dermatological differences in skin thickness, healing rates, and sensitivity. Pediatric specifications include 25-30% adhesion reduction for gentle removal, while geriatric considerations incorporate fragile skin protocols and medication interaction factors. Regulatory requirements reflect FDA guidance for age-specific labeling and testing protocols. Cost Structure Modeling: Component costs represent 2024 market pricing from qualified medical device suppliers in North America and Europe. Manufacturing complexity tiers assume ISO 13485-certified facilities with appropriate clean room classifications. Volume considerations incorporate equipment amortization schedules and economies of scale achievable at different production levels. Regulatory and testing costs reflect typical expenditures for US market entry, excluding clinical study variability based on specific indications. All specifications represent industry benchmarks and typical ranges. Actual performance, costs, and requirements will vary based on specific device design, intended use population, manufacturing location, supplier relationships, and regulatory strategy. Recommendations should be validated through application-specific testing and consultation with qualified suppliers and regulatory professionals.

Adhesive Type

Skin Compatibility

Adhesion Strength

Removal Ease

Cost

Best Applications

Limitations

Silicone-Based

Acrylic-Based

Hydrocolloid

Wear Duration

Recommended Adhesive

Backing Material

Key Design Considerations

Typical Applications

Regulatory Focus

Hours (1 - 24)

Days (1 - 7)

Days (7 - 30)

Activity Level

Mechanical Stress

Adhesive Requirements

Design Features

Testing Requirements

Cost Impact

Sedentary (Limited Mobility)

Active (Daily Activities)

Sports/Athletic (High Intensity)

Population

Skin Characteristics

Design Priorities

Material Considerations

Regulatory Requirements

Special Testing

Pediatric (0 - 17 years)

Adult (18 - 64 years)

Geriatric (65+ years)

Cost Component

Low-Cost Option

Mid-Range Option

Premium Option

Performance Trade-Offs

Volume Considerations

Adhesive Materials

Backing Materials

Manufacturing Complexity

Regulatory / Testing

Assumptions & METHODOLOGY

Your innovation Just Might change the world. But the odds are against you. We help you turn Just Might into Just Mighty.

BOYD BIOMEDICAL, INC.

COMPANY

SERVICES

KNOWLEDGE CENTER

QUALIFICATIONS

NEWSROOM